Featured Recipe
Bacon Cream Cheese Mushrooms
By Kate
"
Bacon and cream cheese stuffed mushrooms with a tweak. Swap sour cream for cream cheese for tang. Mushrooms cleaned with damp cloth, not soaked. Bacon crisped, rendered fat saved for flavor. Stems chopped fine, cooked in bacon grease until soft and fragrant. Garlic and onion powders paired with sharp aged cheddar instead of Parmesan bring sharper notes. Filling spooned generously into caps, baked till bubbling and edges golden. Visual cues prioritized over timers; bacon fat aroma rising signals progress. Serves 18 to 22, about 60 calories each, adaptable to ingredients on hand.
"
Prep:
18 min
Cook:
25 min
Total:
43 min
Serves:
20 servings
appetizers
party food
bacon lovers
Introduction
Those mushrooms don’t clean well if dunked. Wipe them, dry, no soggy caps. Bacon thick cuts better here; thin strips dry too fast, burn easier. Crisp but not blackened — listen to that steady sizzle. Save fat, the good stuff. Mushroom stems carry flavor, don’t toss. Chop fine, cook in bacon grease—brown until you smell that deep, earthy aroma and see softened bits sticking to pan edges. Mix with cream cheese but add sour cream for tang punch, keeps filling lively, balances fat. Sharp cheddar swaps Parmesan—stronger bite, melts differently. Garlic and onion powders never fresh minced here, uniform taste, less stringy bits. Apply filling thick into caps, baking temp gently lower than usual to avoid drying mushrooms out. Watch bubbling cheese and slight golden tops, that’s visual doneness. Don’t rely on timer alone; some ovens run hot, some slow. Cool a few, filling sets, perfect mouthfeel. Salting last step — bacon saltiness variable, skip or add cautiously, no one likes salty mush. Smoke paprika optional but brings surprising depth, small twist if you want more flavor layers. Bonus: clean skillet between bacon and stem cook to prevent burnt residue spoiling flavor. Practical, no fluff.
Ingredients
About the ingredients
Mushrooms vary in size; pick uniform if you want even baking, but mixing sizes tests your timing skills. White button or cremini both work. Clean with damp towel; avoid washing under water. Mushrooms soak it up and steam instead of roast; dry surfaces essential. Thick-sliced bacon preferred — more fat to render and crisp up slowly, flavor your filling better. Thin bacon strips can overcook, get tough. Cream cheese is foundation, sour cream shakes up texture and flavor. Can substitute Greek yogurt but expect less richness. Parmesan replaced with sharp aged cheddar for its melting and stronger profile, try manchego or gouda as alternatives. Garlic and onion powders offer even seasoning, garlic powder avoids raw garlic bite. Bacon grease levels regulated; too much makes filling greasy, too little sacrifices flavor. Keep about 2 tablespoons. Smoked paprika a nod to extra smoky aroma, optional but potent. Adjust spices and salt by tasting filling before stuffing — safe with small clean spoon sample from mixture bowl.
Method
Technique Tips
Oven set a bit lower than typical 350°F to 345°F slows baking, keeps mushrooms from drying, lets filling heat evenly without burning edges. Bacon crisping demands steady medium heat; too high, it burns, leaving bitter flavors. Low and slow is better for rendering fat. Save fat, critical layer of flavor. Chop stems fine but not mush; texture gives bite to filling. Cook stems in bacon fat until softened and lightly browned around edges — smell changes from raw earthiness to rich aroma, that’s your cue to stop. Mix filling gently, avoid over stirring for silky texture without heaviness. Season carefully; bacon salt content differs by brand. Stuff caps slightly heaping, pressing down ensures filling adheres during baking. Bake uncovered on greased pan or lined with foil to catch drips. Watch surfaces vigilantly past 18 minutes. Cheese should melt and brown in spots. Filling bubbles but mushroom cap edges stay intact, wrinkling signals done. Pull from oven, rest 5 minutes, filling firms, easier to handle, more satisfying bite. Store leftovers tightly wrapped — filling can weep if exposed to air too long. Reheat gently at 300°F or microwave low power.
Chef's Notes
- 💡 Choose mushrooms carefully. Uniform sizes bake evenly. Too small? Slice larger ones. Clean with damp cloth, never soak. Avoid soggy caps.
- 💡 Bacon matters. Thick-cut preferred. Render fat slowly on medium heat. Sounds tell you when ready. Listen for even sizzling, not burning.
- 💡 Mix fillings gently. Don’t overmix, keep some texture. Cream cheese is essential — can swap with Greek yogurt. Expect less richness though.
- 💡 Watch cooking time loosely. Visual cues matter. Edge browning, bubbling cheese, that’s doneness. Every oven behaves differently; yours might run hot.
- 💡 Salt is tricky. Bacon has varying saltiness. Add cautiously. Sample the filling before stuffing mushrooms. Adjust seasoning for balance.
Kitchen Wisdom
Can I use other cheeses?
Yes, try gouda or manchego instead of cheddar. Flavor shifts but still good. Texture changes too, gooeyness.
What if I don’t have sour cream?
Substitute plain yogurt or skip entirely. Might lose tang but still tasty. Adjust other flavors.
How do I store leftovers?
Wrap tightly in plastic to keep filling moist. Fridge for a few days but use up fast, flavor fades.
Filling turns runny, why?
Overbaking can ruin texture. Keep an eye on bubbling and browning. Mushrooms release moisture, don’t dry out.
