Featured Recipe
Herb Garlic Beef Tenderloin
By Kate
"
Trim and tie the beef to even thickness. Season with salt and pepper. Mash butter with garlic, mustard, rosemary, and thyme. Brown roast on all sides in hot skillet until edges crust. Place sliced onions and fresh herbs around roast. Roast initially at high heat, then reduce oven temp. Compound butter melts slowly, coating meat for layers of flavor. Rest tented to redistribute juices. Slice thick and serve with softened onions. Substitutions for mustard and herbs included. Timing based on feel and color, not clock. A practical guide to balance crust and juicy interior.
"
Prep:
35 min
Cook:
35 min
Total:
70 min
Serves:
6 servings
beef
dinner
special occasion
American steakhouse
roasting
Introduction
Beef tenderloin. Smaller muscle, delicate, lean. Needs taming to get even cook. Otherwise dry edges, raw center. Trimming and tying – simple step that pays off big time. Salt sits a half hour to coax out moisture, then pulls back in to season deeply, crust forms better. Garlic butter mixed with mustard and herbs, better than plain; adds complexity. Browning in hot cast iron, crust crackles loud enough to make you focus. Toss sliced onions around—caramelizing in fat released from meat. Oven start hot to blast flavor, then cool down to finish inside gently. Checking temperature beats guessing. Resting lets flesh relax – no dry bites. Slice thick. Serve right away. No fluff, just muscle. Substitutions so no surprises if missing ingredients. Tips on skillet choice, oil use, broiler fix for stuck sear. Real talk for real cooks.
Ingredients
About the ingredients
Butter is the base for flavor, softened to mix easily but still hold shape when dolloped. Garlic fresh, minced finely so it roasts gently without burning. Mustard brings acidity and heat; Dijon preferred but whole grain or horseradish can swap in for punch. Rosemary and thyme fresh are best; dry herbs lose aromatic oils and risk bitterness. If unavailable, tarragon adds anise notes, sage earthiness. Onions add sweetness and moisture around roast, their slices soak up dripping fat. Olive oil introduced only if cast iron is absent to prevent sticking and tearing crust. Salt and fresh cracked pepper fundamental, must be generous. Tying roast ensures even thickness, prevents uneven cooking and curling – skip it and cross fingers for luck.
Method
Technique Tips
Tying uniform thickness is key for even cook times. Salt meat at least 25 minutes to dry brine—slow process that seasons deeper and helps create crust. Compound butter combines fat, flavor, and aromatics; mustard cuts through fat and balances garlic bite. Searing on cast iron locks juices, creates those brown bits crucial for flavor – hot pan preheated until shimmering or slight smoke. Browning only 1.5–2.5 min per side to avoid overcooking edges. Onions act as natural basting bed in oven, absorb flavors. High oven temp blast accelerates Maillard reaction inside roast; lowering temp slows cooking to avoid toughening meat. Butter applied in stages melts gradually over roast surface, building layers of flavor and moisture. Thermometer indispensable; color unreliable in thick loins. Resting lets muscle fibers relax and soak juices back in — no juice running out when slicing. Slice against grain for tenderness. Common mistake: skipping rest, rushing sear, uneven thickness, not using thermometer, or burning butter atop roast because oven too hot.
Chef's Notes
- 💡 Use timely seasons. Salt plays critical role. Generous at least 30 minutes before cooking. Essential for crust development. Faster crust—less juicy center risk.
- 💡 Tie the roast with twine. Ensures even thickness. Without it, thicker ends burn. Center raw. Thick cuts means uneven cooking, tough edges.
- 💡 Keep pan hot. Sear quickly on all sides. Look for crust forming, about 2 minutes each side. Perfect time for browning; listen for sizzling.
- 💡 Roast at high heat, then reduce. Start 430F to jumpstart browning inside. Lower to 345F to finish cooking gently. Prevents toughness.
- 💡 Use thermometer for doneness. Reliable measure. Visual cues can mislead. Aim for 120F for rare, catch before it rises too much. Resting time crucial.
Kitchen Wisdom
How to fix dry edges on beef?
Thinly slice roast, pan sauté quickly in remaining herb butter. Adds moisture back into meat better than sauce.
What to do if roast too large?
Increase time by 5 to 10 minutes based on weight. Check temp frequently. Don’t just guess.
Best substitute for Dijon mustard?
Use horseradish for punch or whole grain mustard for texture. Both add kick you need in recipe.
Can leftovers be saved?
Yes, cold sliced beef makes great sandwiches or salads. Use sturdy bread. Keep in fridge in airtight container.
