Featured Recipe
Sheet Pan Mix Cookies

By Kate
"
Four cookie flavors baked together on one half sheet pan using one base dough divided into parts. Melted butter replaces some butter for moisture. Milk swaps cream. Fold dry into wet to avoid tough dough. Scatter cinnamon sugar on one quadrant. Chocolate chunks added after baking to preserve shape and texture. Bake til puffy then settles. Tap pan to deflate if too airy. Cool fully then score into 24 bars. Store airtight, room temp, keep fresh up to 5 days if they last.
"
Prep:
20 min
Cook:
22 min
Total:
42 min
Serves:
24 squares
cookies
desserts
sheet pan
baking
Introduction
Butter+sugar become liquid gold first. Melt instead of softened, changes dough texture into more tender crumb. Milk over cream cuts richness slightly, keeps dough workable. Fold in dry ingredients carefully; air and gluten development controlled. Divide dough, jazz each with different flavors. Crush nuts, chips, even pretzels add texture contrast. Flatten. Will rise, then settle—look for edges slightly bronze, center still soft but set. Cooling crucial for slabs to firm, easy slicing. Toss chocolate chips on last minute; no baking chocolate chunks then or they melt flat. Store airtight or will dry out. Mix and match flavors, experiment with pantry finds. Scraps pressed in corners add surprise bites. Sheet pan cookie madness done right.
Ingredients
About the ingredients
Swapped half flour for whole wheat to add nuttiness without heaviness. Baking soda plus cream of tartar creates balanced leavening and subtle rise that settles flat enough for slicing. Melted butter melds sugars quickly for even absorption—skip lumps or grainy spots mean uneven bake. Milk softens dough vs thicker creams for less spread. Cinnamon sugar finish crisps surface with signature snickerdoodle zip. Chocolate chunks sprinkled after avoids melted blobs running wild during bake. Use mix-ins sparingly to prevent dough too stiff. Nod to texture: pretzels for crunch, nuts for chew, chips for melty pockets. Substitute melted coconut oil but expect slight flavor change. Granulated sugar+light brown sugar combo keeps chew and color. No mixer needed, whisk and fold all that’s essential.
Method
Technique Tips
Start preheat before mixing. Melted butter+sugars must be fully combined, break oasis clumps of brown sugar with whisk or fork. Eggs add fat, milk softens batter, vanilla lifts aroma. Dry mix thoroughly beforehand, sieve if lumpy. Fold gently to avoid gluten overdevelopment; dull spatula preferred over whisk or spoon to preserve tenderness. Dividing dough by weight ensures even quadrant sizes, important so each cookie bakes uniformly. Flatten to approx 1/2 inch or just fill pan edges; uneven surfaces cook patchy. Cinnamon sugar dusting is last before bake—adds visual cue and flavor officially stamped. Chocolate chunks never bake inside—they melt too thin. Tap pan on counter post-bake if risen dome persists; gives flat surface for neat bars. Cooling fully crucial; too warm and squares crumble, too cool and chips won’t set. Cut with sharp knife, clean between cuts to prevent dragging dough. Leftovers may lose chewiness but keep sealed airtight.
Chef's Notes
- 💡 First off, use melted butter. It mixes better with sugars. Creates tenderness. Reduce clumps of brown sugar. Whisk well, don’t skip this step.
- 💡 Dividing dough into four parts. Weigh them for consistency better. Avoid uneven baking. Different flavors, textures. Level out the surface.
- 💡 Add mix-ins wisely. Too many can stiffen the dough. Balance flavors—pistachios, pretzels, chocolate all work. Don’t drown in extras.
- 💡 Sprinkle cinnamon sugar before baking. Boosts flavor, gives a nice finish. Check the surface before taking it out. Lightly puffed, set edges. Look for golden.
- 💡 Cool completely on the pan. Cuts easier when firm. Chocolate chunks on top after baking not before—melts too much otherwise.
Kitchen Wisdom
How to achieve the right texture?
Mix butter and sugars thoroughly. No clumps. Eggs add moisture, essential for texture. Avoid overmixing.
What if my cookies spread too much?
More flour can help stabilize. Chilling dough for 30 minutes also helps. Keep an eye on baking time.
Can I substitute ingredients?
Yes, try coconut oil for butter, dairy-free milk instead. Regular flour instead of whole wheat, if needed.
How to store these cookies?
Airtight container works best. Can last up to 5 days. Freshness diminishes. Freeze for longer storage.



