Featured Recipe
Spiced Butternut Squash Soup
By Kate
"
A rich, creamy soup featuring diced butternut squash simmered in vegetable broth instead of chicken, infused with warm cinnamon and nutmeg instead of pumpkin pie spice, a hint of maple syrup replacing brown sugar. Butter and shallots sautéed to translucent sweetness. Pureed until velvety. Finished with heavy cream swirl for richness. Watch the color change to a deep orange and listen for subtle simmering bubbles, signaling squash is tender. Keeps well. Nutmeg adds earthiness, cinnamon offers warmth, maple syrup balances acidity. Nutritionally moderate fat and sodium, low fiber, with vitamins A and C present.
"
Prep:
12 min
Cook:
25 min
Total:
37 min
Serves:
5 servings
soup
vegetarian
fall recipes
Introduction
Peeling butternut squash isn’t glamorous but it sets the tone—firm grip, sharp peeler. Seeds scooped, diced to consistent size so they cook evenly, not one batch mashed, another raw. Butter carries flavor; shallots chosen over onion for subtle sweetness, garlic for aroma. Skip harsh boiling; simmer coax flavors out gently, bubbles faint, not roar. Cream adds silkiness, spices cinnamon and nutmeg replace bland pumpkin pie label; more nuanced, complex. Splash of maple syrup cuts acidity, rounds edges. Blending needs patience, no chunks, uniform texture key. If too thick, thin with broth instead of water for depth. Critical stuff if you want hearty but light meal.
Ingredients
About the ingredients
Butternut squash should feel firm, no soft spots or mold. Fresh garlic prevails over powdered any day; more punch, less flatness. Shallots provide sweeter, nuttier taste than onions, but yellow onion is acceptable if careful to cook long enough to avoid bite. Butter brings richness; use unsalted to control salt addition later. Vegetable broth keeps it vegetarian and lighter. Maple syrup swaps brown sugar, cutting overly sweet trap while adding complexity; honey can work but may overpower. Spices cinnamon and nutmeg strike balance between warmth and subtlety. Heavy cream crucial for velvety mouthfeel; substitute coconut cream for dairy-free version but watch flavor shift. Salt always adjusted to taste with salinity of broth.
Method
Preparation
- Peel the butternut squash carefully; halves measured lengthwise. Use a sturdy spoon to scrape out seeds and stringy bits. Dice into roughly 1-inch cubes for even cooking; consistency is crucial here.
- Mince garlic and dice shallots finely. Butter melts faster when cut into smaller chunks—so slice it beforehand if cold.
- Heat a large pot over medium heat. Drop butter in; it should melt silently, no sputtering. Add shallots and garlic. Cook until translucent, about 5 minutes. Watch carefully; garlic browning too early = bitterness.
- Toss in diced squash; it should sizzle softly as it hits the butter shallot base. Coat evenly to prevent sticking.
- Pour vegetable broth — enough to just cover squash. Too much water dilutes flavor; keep it just submerged.
- Crank heat to bring to gentle simmer. You want tiny bubbles rolling around edges—not a roaring boil. Cover pot loosely. Cook about 25 minutes, stirring occasionally. Squash should yield easily when poked with fork, tender but not mushy.
- Remove from heat. Stir in cream, cinnamon, nutmeg, maple syrup, salt, and fresh black pepper. Spices wake up once heat returns, so mix thoroughly.
- Use immersion blender straight in pot for convenience, blending until soup reaches uniform velvety texture. No chunks or stringy bits. If blender is used, do in small batches; takes less time and safer. Careful of hot splashes.
- Ladle into bowls. Garnish each with a swirl of heavy cream for richness and visual contrast. Serve immediately.
- If soup thickens too much on standing, stir in splash of broth or cream. Reheat low and slow.
- Store leftovers in fridge, covered tightly; will keep up to 3 days.
Cooking
Finishing
Technique Tips
Heat management tops this process. Melt butter quietly to avoid browning early; brown butter would change flavor drastically. Shallots translucent, not golden or burnt, or bitterness invades. Garlic added late but cooked enough to release aroma without crisping. Squash sizzles on contact, proof of hot fat; stir gently to avoid smashing cubes. Simmer, not boil; bubbles delicate, not frantic, to soften but not fray flesh. Fork tender test reliable over timers, since stovetops vary. Off heat mix-in of cream and spices prevents burning delicate dairy or spices. Immersion blender preferred for efficiency and minimal cleanup; careful moves prevent splashes of hot liquid. Garnish adds visual appeal but also luxurious mouthfeel. Adjust thickness post-blend with broth or cream to personal taste; reheating slowly protects texture.
Chef's Notes
- 💡 First, prep squash carefully. Use a heavy, sharp peeler. Watch fingers. Long strokes help avoid spills. Diced pieces even. Keep cubes about an inch. Allows cooking consistency, no mush or crunch. Don't rush this.
- 💡 Melt butter gently. Medium heat, no sizzle. Sauté shallots, garlic for five minutes. Aim translucent—not brown. Early browning creates bitterness. Adjust if necessary. Stir occasionally. Watch carefully to control aroma buildup.
- 💡 Sub broth with chicken if desired. Adds deeper flavor but watch sodium. Maple syrup not just sweet. Cuts acidity in curry of flavors. Consider adding a dash of lemon juice for brightness. Always balance.
- 💡 Cream should mix in cooled pot after heat off. High temp can separate. Integrate spices well—cinnamon and nutmeg wake up flavor when heated. Blend until completely smooth for a velvety texture.
- 💡 Squash may thicken soup later; thin down with broth. Avoid adding water—flavor waters down. Reheat at low temp to protect texture. Cover pot loosely during storage to maintain integrity.
Kitchen Wisdom
How do I prevent sticking?
Keep stirring squash in pot as it cooks. Prevent sticky bits. Thin layer broth covers—keeps ingredients from sticking to the bottom.
What if soup is too thick?
Use broth gradually. Thin mix if paste-y. If feeling too sweet, add a splash of vinegar, cuts heaviness quick. Adjust seasoning before serving.
How to store leftovers?
Refrigerator up to three days works. Cool soup before sealing it tight. Separate containers to prolong fresh taste. Avoid freezing for best texture.
Can I use other squash?
Yes, any firm squash can work. Acorn squash or kabocha—slightly differ in flavor. Cut pieces smaller, adjust timing as needed. Watch texture closely.
